The Popeyes chicken sandwich quickly sold out all over the country when it launched in August, including in Omaha, Lincoln and Council Bluffs.
But who needs it?
I’ve had a lot of fun spending my week eating all the other great fried chicken sandwiches at locally owned restaurants around Omaha (and one in Council Bluffs). In fact, I ate three in the course of the day yesterday. It’s a difficult job, but I’m persevering for you.
It turns out there are some real hidden gems in the fried chicken sandwich category, including two that I suggest you get out and try long before that Popeyes fast-food version gets back into stock.
Without further ado, here are seven great options, including two under $5 and one that’s buy one, get one free every Tuesday.
The chicken sandwich at Stirnella, 3814 Farnam St.

The fried chicken sandwich at Stirnella, in the Blackstone District, stands out because the meat is dark, made with a chicken thigh instead of the more common chicken breast.
Of all the chicken sandwiches I tried, this is the one I can’t stop thinking about. There’s one key difference in Stirnella’s sandwich: It’s made with a locally raised Plum Creek Farms chicken thigh instead of the white meat used in every other sandwich I sampled. The meat is juicier and more flavorful, and it all comes together gloriously: extra-crispy but thinly breaded meat sits with buttermilk crème fraîche, hot sauce, house-made sweet pickles, sweet pepper relish and shaved lettuce, all on a brioche bun. It’s pricey at $16, but worth every penny.
The fried chicken sandwich at Lincoln’s Pub, 157 West Broadway, Council Bluffs

The sandwich at Lincoln’s Pub, in Council Bluffs, comes with an Iowa-sized chicken breast, made in the same style as the state’s popular pork tenderloin sandwiches. Its slaw is standout.
If you’ve ever had an Iowa pork tenderloin sandwich and secretly wished the pork were chicken, Lincoln’s Pub has your back. Its chicken sandwich comes with a chicken breast at least twice the size of the bun, served with house-made sweet barbecue sauce and one of the more delicious slaws I encountered, chock full of, among other ingredients, chopped Brussels sprouts and spicy sliced raw jalapeños.
The Birdhouse Slider at Nite Owl, 3902 Farnam St.

Nite Owl’s Birdhouse slider includes fried chicken, a honey-sriracha sauce and a Southern bacon slaw.
These petite sandwiches come one-per-order for $5, and if you’re planning to mow through a plate of totchos, as all people should at Nite Owl, then one slider is the perfect size. They come drenched in a spicy-sweet honey sriracha sauce and are topped with a salty Southern bacon slaw. The chicken itself never fails to be crisp and delicious.
The Block Deluxe with Nashville hot chicken at Block 16, 1611 Farnam St.

Block 16 serves its Block Deluxe sandwich with the option of Nashville hot chicken. It comes topped with mayo, crispy bacon, cheddar and horseradish slaw on a brioche bun.
The Nashville Hot Chicken B16 Deluxe runs a little under the radar. The sandwich is generally made with shaved prime rib, and the chicken is a secondary option. All you have to do is look at the photo of this thing to know it’s going to be great. The Nashville hot chicken tenders are local, from Plum Creek Farms, and then they’re fried to a golden brown and topped with mayo, bacon, cheddar and horseradish slaw, all on a soft brioche bun.
The Dirty Bird at Blatt Beer + Table, various locations

The Dirty Bird at Blatt Beer + Table comes topped with Buffalo sauce, blue cheese and bacon, among other ingredients.
Blatt’s Indian-spiced chicken is one of my personal favorite chicken variations in the city, but don’t skip its Dixie-fried chicken, either. The Dirty Bird puts that crispy, juicy chicken front and center, and it’s topped with Applewood-smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato, red onion, coleslaw and two sauces: sriracha Buffalo and blue cheese. Of course, it’s served on a buttery brioche bun.
The Dodge City at Jack & Mary’s Restaurant, 655 N. 114th St.

The fried chicken sandwich from Jack & Mary’s Restaurant comes served with lettuce, tomato and mayo; or as the “Dodge City” with bacon, barbecue sauce and cheddar cheese.
The Dodge City is the most old-school of any of the fried chicken sandwiches we tried. It’s an oversized chicken breast battered with Jack & Mary’s thicker, very-bready-in-texture coating, then slathered with barbecue sauce, cheddar cheese and a couple strips of crispy bacon. The restaurant also serves a more classic version with just mayo, lettuce and tomato, but we much preferred the bacon-cheesy variety; the cheese and sauce paired nicely with the distinct style of the coating.
The Chicken Sandy at Bob’s Doughnuts, 3824 Farnam St.

The inexpensive Chicken Sandy at Bob’s Doughnuts was the most reasonably priced we tried. It comes classic or spicy, dipped in hot sauce.
This is your value chicken sandwich if there ever was one: At just $3.80, it’s fast-food pricing at a non-fast-food restaurant. On Tuesdays, Chicken Sandies are buy one, get one free, making this even more of a steal. I got mine spicy, though there’s also a regular version. Spicy it was, with the whole piece of meat dunked in a Buffalo sauce that packed a punch. It’s also messy: The chicken slid around between a hefty slather of mayo, two ripe red tomatoes and a big piece of lettuce. All I’m saying: Don’t try and eat this one in your car.
Food reviews from The World-Herald
Forno
Hits: creative Tigelle, the signature wood fired pizza crust and an excellent selection of roasted vegetables, particularly the cauliflower.
Misses: A salmon tartare arrived aggressively salty. I wished for more flavor from the mushroom arancini. Read the full review here
Taste of India
Hits: Gingery, thick dal and a matar paneer loaded with Indian cheese and tender green peas.
Misses: I wish a dipping sauce came with the naan, which is otherwise good but can be a bit doughy at its center. Read the full review here
Kathmandu Momo Station
Hits: The momos, particularly the pork and chicken, are standout. And when the Burmese ramen is available, its a light, fresh version of the dish.
Misses: We wished the filling on the vegan momo had a less crumbly texture. Read the full review here
Vitality Bowls
Hits: The bright pink, creamy açaí bowls pack flavor, texture and healthy ingredients.
Misses: One green smoothie tasted too bitter for our liking. Read the full review here
Osaka Steakhouse & Sushi Bar
Hits: The simple rolls, including a tuna cucumber, and sushi tasted fresh and clean. Hibachi items come with plenty of vegetables and nicely cooked meat.
Misses: Yellowtail sushi had a chewy finish, and sides, like salads and miso soup, are pretty basic. Read the full review here
Rosati's Pizza
Hits: The Italian beef sandwich was the best of what we tried.
Misses: Across the board, the crust (thin, deep dish and a special "double dough") had very little flavor. A thin-crust pepperoni slice was extremely greasy. Read the full review here
Ansel's Pastrami and Bagels
Hits: The beer-boiled bagels are great, particularly as part of a breakfast sandwich. Don't skip the house-made pastrami.
Misses: The variety of bagel flavors often seemed slim. Read the full review here
High Peak Asian Restaurant
Hits: Burmese specialties including the chicken kebat, tea leaf salad and bun tay kauswer
Misses: Service can be slow, particularly when it comes time for the check. Read the full review here
Lincoln's Pub
Hits: The Le Pig Mac, with pork patties; an interesting take on bangers and mash and a tasty pastrami Reuben.
Misses: The chips with a buffalo chicken dip arrived greasy. Read the full review here
Olive & Ash Pizza Co.
Hits: The thicker, pan-style crust was best, particularly with the house combination of toppings.
Misses: The thin crust isn't quite New York style — it's too thick for that. We wished for more flavor from the ingredients, which often got overwhelmed by cheese. Read the full review here
Modern Love
Hits: There is not a misstep on the new, larger menu. Particular favorites? The minty hummus platter with beautiful vegetables, a delicious mushroom bourguignon and a mind-blowing cinnamon roll.
Misses: None. Read the full review here
BurgerIM
Hits: The wagyu slider and the classic, full-sized burger were good, as were a couple of the more creative patties, like lamb.
Misses: The dry aged slider had a chewy texture, and grilled chicken arrived dry. The greens on a California-style burger were tinged with brown. Read the full review here
Indian Bowl
Hits: The chicken curry and the vindaloo were the best of the entrees. A creamy mango lassi cooled things down.
Misses: The tikka masala was sweeter than we'd had before. The sauces across the board could have used more depth of flavor. Read the full review here
Rathskeller Bier Haus
Hits: A curry sausage, a tasty cheese and meat plate and an interesting take on macaroni and cheese made with homemade spätzle instead of pasta.
Misses: The goulash is rib-sticking good, but we wished our order had been hotter. Read the full review here
Angus Burgers & Shakes
Hits: The classic drive-in burger was a huge hit, and one of the more simple burgers on the menu. The loaded Nebraska farmer, a sort of breakfast burger, also pleased.
Misses: We wished the thin patties could have been cooked less in almost every case. A Reuben burger was overloaded with Thousand Island dressing. Read the full review here.
J. Gilbert's Wood-Fired Steaks & Seafood
Hits: All steaks but one arrived perfectly cooked and well seasoned. The creamed corn was a surprisingly delicious side, and the coconut cake an excellent dessert.
Misses: Steak frites arrived medium instead of medium rare, as ordered. We wished for more pretzel flavor in pretzel-coated onion rings. Read the full review here
Ika San
Hits: Fish is fresh and tasty across the board. We especially enjoyed the seafood ramen (spicy!), the poke ceviche bowl and the spicy tuna tots.
Misses: A donburi bowl arrived a little heavy on the spicy mayo. Read full review here
Oklahoma Joe's Bar-B-Cue
Hits: The smoked half chicken and the pulled pork were especially tasty.
Misses: Ribs, brisket and burnt ends suffered from uneven execution. Read full review here
Mouth of the South
Hits: Crab cakes, smoky gumbo and flavorful etoufee are all excellent.
Misses: The crab dip is severly lacking in the main ingredient. Read full review here
Shahi India Grill
Hits: Butter chicken, naan, a carrot dessert and a flavorful Indian tea.
Misses: Some sauces and soups could have been thicker in texture. Read full review here
Lighthouse Pizza & Fries
Hits: The best of the house pizzas we tried are the Sparky (just as good as what's at the original location) and the flavorful vegetarian pesto. The hand-cut fries are tasty.
Misses: Some house pizzas are over-the-top, heavy on sauces and toppings. The super fries are intense, though tasty. Don't think about calories. Read full review here
The Drover
Hits: The beef at The Drover is legendary for a reason, as is the whiskey marinade, which never overwhelms the meat. Sides are hearty and filling, and the salad bar is a classic.
Misses: We wished for bartenders that could make a few more classic cocktails. Read full review here
Rally Coffee Co.
Hits: The toast selections are tasty and creative, even when they only feature bread and butter. The coffee and coffee drinks, particularly a cardamom latte, are excellent.
Misses: We wished for salsa that wasn't half frozen with an order of breakfast tacos. Read full review here
Timber Creek Pizza Pub & Grill
Hits: The fried pickles are especially splurge-worthy, and the pizzas, with a mid-weight crust and plenty of toppings, are rich. Craft cocktails were surprisingly inventive.
Misses: The thick layer of cream cheese on one pizza was a bit much for me personally, but I can see how the masses might disagree. Read full review here
Oasis Falafel
Hits: The falafel at Oasis is super crispy and really flavorful. I appreciate that all the sauces, the hummus and the baba ganoush are made from scratch with care.
Misses: We liked all the food; I mostly wish Oasis were open more (its owners say Saturday lunch is coming soon.) Read full review here
Mayne St. Market
Hits: The hot sandwiches, including the Reuben and a club, were great, as was the matzo ball soup.
Misses: A side of pasta salad was just OK; the chicken salad was good but we liked the hot sandwiches more. Read full review here
Butterfish
Hits: High-end takes on takeout favorites, like a duck confit egg roll, are fun and tasty.
Misses: One sushi dish, while creative, was way too spicy for our taste. Read full review here
Jinya Ramen Bar
Hits: The sprouted up and spicy umami miso ramen bowls were both great. Don't skip the excellent house made gyoza.
Misses: A pork bun was pretty basic. We had service issues the first evening. Read full review here
Acadian Grille
Hits: The southern classics were all great, particularly the red beans and rice and the shrimp and grits.
Misses: I wished for a thicker sauce on a gouda mac and cheese. Read full review here
Culprit Cafe Midtown Crossing
Hits: Food, particularly bread, is great across the board. A pot pie, a side of crispy potatoes and a gravlax sandwich were all hits.
Misses: We wished we'd have gotten our cocktails before our entrees at dinner. Read full review here
Mode de Vie
Hits: A flavorful, herbacious cassoulet and a high-end take on the diner burger were both tasty. The cheese and meat board is also worth sampling.
Misses: We wished for more flavor out of a chicken and puff pastry dish, and some servers need work when it comes to explaining the sparkling wine list. Read full review here
The Stave Wine & Cheese Parlour
Hits: The Stave specializes in cheese and meat plates, and the Wisconsin cheddars are particularly tasty.
Misses: No misses on the cheese boards, but the service can be slow. Read full review here
Fauxmaha Hot Dogs
Hits: All the dogs were tasty, though the mac and cheese and the banh mi dogs were favorites.
Misses: We liked all the dogs we tried. Read full review here
Freezing
Hits: The candy and cookie flavored rolled ice creams were the best.
Misses: The texture on the rolled ice cream is shard-like and melts fast. Read full review here
The Hunger Block
Hits: The arroz chaufa, Latin fried rice, is great. So are the tacos. If you like mezcal, be sure to try the smoky rosemary flower cocktail.
Misses: Chips one night arrived cold and greasy, and the meat on an arepa sandwich was dry. Read full review here
The Grove Juicery
Hits: The sweet Jane green juice was my favorite of all I tried.
Misses: The acai bowl had more ice than fruit, and was scant on toppings compared to others I've tried. Read full review here
Best Bison
Hits: The bison burger, the pommes frites and a chocolate milkshake with good texture pleased.
Misses: A brat and a sausage both had a too-chewy texture, and a Reuben, though made with nice meat, was soggy. Read full review here
Stokin' Goat
Hits: A tender grilled octopus appetizer and a modern take on shrimp scampi pleased.
Misses: Overcooked beef was a disappointment, as was too-tough duck in an otherwise creative salad. Read full review here
Yamato Sushi
Hits: The simpler plates off the sushi train — seaweed salad, stuffed tofu skin, a spicy tuna roll and a rainbow roll — were the best of what we had. Off the menu, we had a nice piece of yellowtail sushi.
Misses: A lot of the "fancier" sushi rolls are coated in a thick layer of mayo-based aioli; no matter the fillings, the heavy-handed sauce makes them all taste the same.
801 Grill
Hits: The Umami burger was outstanding, and the ribs rank among the best I've had in town. Also: The Old Bay-seasoned fries and the cheesecake.
Misses: A grilled asparagus side came with a woody texture, especially near the bottom of the stalk. Read full review here
Craft Sliders + Beer
Hits: The house blend of beef has great flavor, and when we asked for a slider done medium, the kitchen achieved it. The vegan jackfruit and hot chicken sliders are good, too.
Misses: Small, store bought croutons on the salad were disappointing. Fried cauliflower, while tasty, was a bit odd served on a bed of greens with a side of cheese sauce. Service is spotty. Read full review here
Dairy Chef
Hits: There’s tons of ice cream treats on the menu, we especially liked the cookie sandwich. The over-the-top garbage burger is worth sampling.
Misses: The heavy toppings on a Reuben sandwich made the bread get kind of soggy. Read full review here
Chaima African Cuisine
Hits: Grilled tilaipa served with fried plantains and cassava couscous is excellent.
Misses: Grilled chicken needed hot sauce to improve its texture. Read full review here
Paddy McGown's Pub and Grill
Hits: Solid wings, a tasty Reuben and an addictive, cheesy corn nugget appetizer called Blarney stones. Decent onion rings, too.
Misses: The kitchen had trouble cooking its burger to a requested medium doneness. Read full review here
HipBao
Hits: The filling in a curry beef bao had good flavor, and the potstickers were the best of the dumplings.
Misses: The kitchen couldn't execute the dish on the specials menu, we received two cold bao, and many of the other dumplings and bao we tried tasted mostly of raw dough. Service was spotty at best. Read full review here
M's Pub
Hits: All your old favorites are just as good as you remember.
Misses: The specials menu was hit-and-miss: A recent halibut special with Asian flavors pleased, but a duck special, while nicely cooked, had flavors that didn’t make sense together. Read full review here
Dante Pizzeria Napoletana
Hits: The pizza at the second location is just as good, from top to bottom, as what diners find out west. A chicken puttanesca had the perfect balance of savory and salty flavors.
Misses: The crust on a pressed salumi sandwich got soggy from too much liquidy giardiniera pepper sauce. Read full review here
Steak & Grapes
Hits: The appetizers are creative, and we especially enjoyed fried ribs and a take on escargot with beef and funky Gorgonzola cheese.
Misses: Fish and chips were too heavily breaded and bland, and scallops were overwhelmed with cheese and cheese crackers in a baked dish. Read full review
TNT Walking Taco
Hits: The namesake walking taco is the best thing we tried; I especially appreciated the wide variety of fresh toppings, though I wished for more diversity in sauce flavors.
Misses: A taquito — even when it's free — wasn't great, with a greasy exterior and flavorless filling. And a fried taco shell also disappointed, with a greasy, soggy finish. Read full review here
Farine + Four
Hits: The baguette at Farine + Four is one of the best in Omaha; so is the croissant and the delectable Tosca, an almond-scented dessert.
Misses: The fried chicken on a sandwich I tried one day was a touch greasy. Read full review here
Hits: The baguette at Farine + Four is one of the best in Omaha; so is the croissant and the delectable Tosca, an almond-scented dessert.
Misses: The fried chicken on a sandwich I tried one day was a touch greasy.
Amateur Coffee Parlor
Hits: The house-roasted coffee beans are great, and I especially liked brewing the "affogato" bag at home. Drinks made at the shop didn't disappoint, either.
Misses: I liked everything I tried. Read full review here
Early Bird
Hits: A surprisingly good Reuben sandwich and the Bird Cage, slices of French toast with eggs at their center.
Misses: The hash browns come served in a tiny tower, but the design means just the top is crispy. I wished for better bread in both the cinnamon toast, an appetizer, and on the hippie sandwich. Read full review here
Chocolat Abeille
Hits: We tried all 19 chocolates in the case one day, and none dissapointed. Favorites included the hazelnut honey crunch, the tea-infused Paris and the sweet-tart passion fruit.
Misses: Tina Tweedy is making a chocolate for every taste, and there isn't a bad one in the bunch. Read full review here
Yoshitomo
Hits: For the adventurous, there’s plenty, but one of my favorite moments had to be the hamachos, a play on nachos made with hamachi and chicharrones.
Misses: We didn’t have a bad dish at Yoshitomo, and owner David Utterback’s focus on quality, freshness and creativity is the reason why. Read full review here
The Bánh Mì Shop
Hits: The Bánh Mì special cold cut, the most classic of the sandwiches, hit all the right notes: fresh pickled vegetables, warm pork and a slather each of pate and mayonnaise. The lemongrass marinade and hoisin on the grilled pork also pleased.
Misses: The only sandwich I wished had more flavor was the chicken bánh mì. Read full review here
Monarch Prime and Bar
Hits: The restaurant’s specialty is a 45-ounce wagyu tomahawk chop that’s aged in-house for 60 days. It’s $150 and serves two to three and, if you are feeling splurgy, is absolutely worth trying. Monarch’s unexpected take on prime rib is also excellent.
Misses: An elk osso bucco had good flavor, but the meat’s texture was too dry. Read full review here
1000 Degrees Neapolitan Pizzeria
Hits: Buffalo wings were surprisingly tasty, with plenty of meat and a spicy sauce. The margherita pizza on the thinner crust was the best of the three we tried.
Misses: A menu with pictures can make things tricky. Pizzas I saw on the restaurant’s website had deeply browned crust and crust bubbles; those I tried in real life lacked those qualities. Read full review here
Post a comment as
Report
Watch this discussion.