A look at what's on the new label
The new “common names” for beef and pork have two components: a cut identifier (sirloin or chuck, for example) and a cut form or shape (steak, roast, chop or filet). Several cuts of pork will now match the names for similar beef cuts.
The label will indicate the class, identifiers to differentiate cuts with the same common name, whether bone-in or boneless and the cutting standard. It will include preparation or cooking tips.
New names in the meat case
Examples of how some cuts of beef and pork were labeled before and after the new names:
» Boneless shoulder top blade steak boneless flat iron, now flat iron steak
» Beef under blade boneless steak, beef chuck eye edge or boneless pot roast, now Denver steak
» Beef rib ribeye lip-on bone in, now ribeye
» Beef loin tenderloin full boneless, now tenderloin
» Beef loin bone in, now porterhouse steak
» Pork loin top loin chop, now porterhouse chop
» Pork loin rib chop, now ribeye chop
» Bone-in pork loin chop, now T-bone chop
» Top loin pork chop, now New York chop
» Pork butt, now Boston roast
Don't know your pork butts from your rump roasts? It may be getting a little easier.
The American meat industry is rolling out a refresh of the often confusing 40-year-old system used for naming the various cuts of beef, pork, lamb and veal. That's because the system — the Uniform Retail Meat Identification Standards, or URMIS — was designed more for the needs of retailers and butchers than for the convenience of harried shoppers more familiar with Shake 'n Bake than boneless shank cuts.
The bottom line is that meat counter confusion isn't good for sales. So after nearly two years of consumer research, the National Pork Board, the Beef Checkoff Program and federal agriculture officials have signed off on an updated labeling system that should hit stores just in time for prime grilling season.
In all, more than 350 cuts of pork and beef (veal and lamb updates are coming later) will sport the new labels, which will include not only simplified names, but also detailed characteristics of the meat and cooking guidelines. So what once was called pork butt — and actually does not come from the pig's nether region — will now be called a Boston roast and be described as a bone-in pork shoulder.
“The problem is consumers didn't really understand the names that were being used, and still don't,” said Patrick Fleming, director of retail marketing for the Pork Board. “The names confused consumers to the point where they'd go, 'You know, the information doesn't help me know how to use it, so I'm going to stop using it.' That was a wake-up call for both the beef industry and pork industry.”
Where appropriate, the new labels also will use universal terms across species — a bone-in loin cut will be called a T-bone whether it's pork or beef — as well as reduce label clutter. Before the update, a properly labeled sirloin steak would be called a “beef loin top sirloin steak, boneless.” Now it will be called ... a sirloin steak.
Other examples of the changes: The cut of meat previously called “beef bottom round heel side boneless” will now be labeled “merlot steak.” A “pork loin center rib sliced bone-in” will be called a “ribeye roast.”
The change comes while America is at a culinary crossroad. Interest in food as entertainment is at an all-time high, but knowledge of food and cooking has ebbed. Farmers markets are booming, but so is the processed food industry. Still, more people are asking more questions about their food, and the massive meat industry (pork and beef alone account for nearly $40 billion in annual retail sales) is hoping to answer them.
Meat labels are federally regulated. And though the URMIS system is a voluntary one, nearly 85 percent of food retailers use it. Those who don't must use either alternative federally approved labels, or submit their own for approval. The backbone of URMIS, which was launched in 1973, is butchering and anatomical terminology. Even at launch, consumer understanding of that was weak.
“That old system just wasn't really doing its job to communicate to the consumer,” said Trevor Amen, director of market intelligence for the Beef Checkoff Program. “If you're a butcher or a meat cutter, you really know what part of the animal it comes from. But if you're a consumer, you just want to know what it is and what to do with it.”
Now it falls to retailers to implement the changes and educate consumers. The industry will help, including launching a marketing effort to spread the word. Still, there is concern the very changes the industry hopes will help consumers may end up confusing them even more.
Though the new names may catch on, already published cookbooks and recipes could call for meats by different names. Will people know to buy a New York chop if a pork recipe calls for a top loin chop? And what about older cooks who grew up with legacy names, such as pork rump (now called leg sirloin)?
“The intent certainly was not to confuse consumers, but there are some situations where that certainly could happen,” said Bucky Gwartney, a federal agriculture marketing specialist who worked with the meat industry to formulate the changes. “We tried to make sure even though some of these changes were fairly dramatic, they were still grounded in the original cut (of meat).”