As the sharing economy emerges, states and cities face decisions on public policy

Font Size:
Default font size
Larger font size

Posted: Friday, January 10, 2014 12:00 am | Updated: 11:04 am, Tue Mar 25, 2014.

Websites and applications that let consumers rent out their home or give a stranger a ride in their car for a few bucks will drive sweeping changes in public policy in the coming year as cities and states rethink how they govern the so-called sharing economy.

In the past year, sharing economy businesses have moved from the fringe to the mainstream. But 2014 will be the year policymakers and regulators decide how much freedom to give these companies, according to sharing economy leaders, academics and attorneys.

“Every city will be looking at its laws and reviewing them,” said Janelle Orsi, an Oakland, Calif.-based attorney and director of the Sustainable Economies Law Center. “The dust is going to settle in the next year. A few cities have outright banned these companies, but they will rethink that.”

The sharing economy refers broadly to companies, many of which make mobile apps, that provide services using things people already own, whether that's a car, home or the clothes in their closet. It gives service providers the opportunity to make some extra cash as, for instance, an ad hoc taxi service, hotel or home-cleaning service.

Until recently, these entrepreneurs have been operating largely unregulated.

California in September became the first state to recognize ride-sharing as a legitimate transportation service with new regulations. It was seen as a landmark victory for ride-sharing and all sharing economy companies. Now, experts say, cities across the country are making room for services that just a year ago were slapped with cease-and-desist orders: Seattle has proposed regulations to legalize, with heavy restrictions, ride-sharing services, and Denver recently added public parking spots without meters for car-sharing programs.

“The most surprising thing is how fast it's gone from crazy idea to obvious,” said Sunil Paul, chief executive officer and co-founder of Sidecar, a San Francisco-based ride-sharing service.

Still, Orsi cautions that public policymakers must wrestle with difficult health, taxation, safety and other issues in clearing the way for the new sharing economy services. What happens, for example, when ride-sharing cars crash, when rented homes are vandalized or when boutique hotels crop up in quiet residential neighborhoods?

“That's going to put pressure on the policymakers to try to understand this, and try to understand what is their role relative to innovation,” said Susan Shaheen, director of innovative mobility research at the University of California-Berkeley Transportation Sustainability Research Center and an expert in car sharing. “They have a role in terms of public policy, but they have to balance that with not stifling innovation.”

In the coming year, ride-sharing companies Sidecar and Lyft will have to undergo vehicle safety checks and audits by state authorities. Meanwhile, ride-sharing company Uber awaits a state ruling on how its black car service, which dispatches limousines or high-end sedans to passengers, will be regulated. How the regulations unfold in California could determine how other cities and states regulate the industry, and whether cities that have pushed out ride-sharing — including Philadelphia, New York and Austin, Texas — will change their minds.

Advocates of the sharing economy argue that it makes better use of resources and creates jobs.

Kathleen Ensign of San Francisco began selling clothes about two years ago on Poshmark, a Menlo Park, Calif.-based fashion-sharing platform. Ensign, a fashion blogger who works at the Gap, makes about $300 a month selling clothes through Poshmark. She used to haul her used clothes — she often buys items to photograph for her blog and wears them just once or twice — to consignment stores on Haight Street, where she'd get 30 percent of whatever the clothes sold for. On Poshmark, she keeps 80 percent.

“I can price the items,” she said. “I have much more control.”

The sharing economy also comes with costs. Shaheen noted that Bay Area public officials will have to weigh decisions such as designating public parking for car-sharing services or occupying public or private property for a bike station. The Bay Area Air Quality Management District helped launch a bike-sharing pilot last year, and the $11.2million program is funded by public agencies.

“It's the public providing a better service for the public,” said Damian Breen, who oversees the program at the air district.

Meanwhile, pressure grows for the sharing economy to resolve security concerns and lawsuits. Airbnb, which launched in San Francisco in 2008 and lets people list and book vacation accommodations around the world online or on a cellphone, continues to face allegations of tax avoidance and concerns about homes being vandalized. Uber, Lyft and Sidecar, meanwhile, still face lawsuits from cab companies and drivers.

Sidecar: San Francisco-based ride-sharing service. Launched in 2012 and now in 10 cities in four states and the District of Columbia.

Lyft: San Francisco-based ride-sharing service. Launched in 2012 and now in 20 cities across 13 states and the District of Columbia.

Uber: Black car service. Launched in 2010 in San Francisco and now in dozens of cities in 25 countries. Added SUV and compact car services.

Task Rabbit: An online and mobile marketplace that connects neighbors for tasks. Launched in 2008 in Boston and moved its headquarters to San Francisco. It has expanded to 17 cities in the U.S., plus the District of Columbia, and recently to London. Its workforce of thousands includes students, unemployed workers, retirees and stay-at-home moms.

Poshmark: A fashion-sharing platform. Launched in 2011 in Menlo Park, Calif. Hosts more than 300,000 sellers who sold a combined 1 million fashion items in the first eight months of 2013.

Airbnb: Lets people list and book vacation accommodations around the world online or on a cellphone. Launched in 2008 in San Francisco; about 4 million people have used the site.

Copyright ©2014 Omaha World-Herald. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, displayed or redistributed for any purpose without permission from the Omaha World-Herald. To purchase rights to republish this article, please contact The World-Herald Store.



Inside Business
To submit an announcement for "Inside Business", click here. For questions call (402) 444-1371 or e-mail

World-Herald Alerts

Want to get World-Herald stories sent directly to your home or work computer? Sign up for's News Alerts and you will receive e-mails with the day's top stories.